Showing posts with label litigious. Show all posts
Showing posts with label litigious. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Who EXACTLY represents the public's interest in civil litigation?

Civil cases between private parties clearly impact the general public; time is used by judges and court personnel, and decisions made by judges and juries can have a profound impact on the lives and businesses of countless people. I have heard many lawyers promote our tort system by arguing that it is very effective in preventing so-called transgressions by corporate America. Their view is that the threat of a lawsuit is key in preventing negligent behaviors before they occur. Of course, the lawyers have not actually been hired to represent the public’s so called best interests; they are hired only to get the most they can for their one client. In fact, no one represents the public’s interests in civil lawsuits, not even the judge, whose sole job is to referee the dispute before him.

What I find most troubling by the argument that these lawyers are acting in the public’s best interests is that they have not asked the public to define what its best interests are. Instead, they somehow equate the public’s best interests as identical to the amount of money they can get for the one client they actually do represent.

But what gives an individual lawyer the insight to know what is and what is not in the public’s best interest? Is the public’s best interest served by causing doctors and hospitals to run countless unnecessary tests just to avoid medical malpractice claims? Is the public’s best interest served by making the cost of doing business and the cost of buying insurance so high as to force companies out of business or to price their products so high as to make them uncompetitive? Is the public’s best interest served by filling operators’ manuals with dozens of useless warnings that very few people ever read, thereby reducing the importance of the few warnings they actually should read, just to have some warning in print to cover any potential lawsuit the company might face?